Is Google TV Web TV part II?

The topic of Google TV is the subject of my latest Engadget column. While I agree TVs need an overhaul and there’s an evolution of that screen that is indeed happening, I’m not convinced that Google’s approach is the correct one. If you need to invoke an IR blaster to make it work, that’s probably a good sign you’re moving in the wrong direction. It’s also hard to see what’s in this that isn’t already for the most part in other platforms such as TiVi Premiere or Media Center PCs. One can’t ignore a Google effort, if for not other reason than it’s Google, but this doesn’t feel on target to me.

I get why the TV is important to Google — it’s a great opportunity for even more ad revenue. But the TV is not a phone or a PC. Consumers are looking for a different type of connected experience in their living rooms, and it’s one that so far has defied every attempt to merge the TV and PC. GoogleTV just feels like the latest in a long line of niche products more likely to appeal to the enthusiast than to the mass market. An old joke has a consumer lamenting for a phone or PC that’s as easy to use as a TV. Google can’t succeed making the TV as complex as your other devices.

2 responses to “Is Google TV Web TV part II?

  1. Couldn’t agree more Michael. I just published a blog post lamenting that google didn’t seize this opportunity to do what it’s best at: search and advertising. The industry really doesn’t need yet another TV “middleware” technology.
    All the big guys like Msft, Intel, Apple insist on trying to fix the whole problem instead of focussing on their core strengths.
    My case, partly inspired by your earlier piece on Google TV, is here

  2. Not sure if Google has the whole answer as yet. But somebody will – and soon. It would seem a nice market for several players. Microsoft. Apple. Google. Yahoo. AOL. These 5 jump to mind. Of course this means that it will probably be answered by a hand full of geniuses and a large amount of venture capital. Time will tell.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s